Lima and Ruiter: How is the MLB not ruling a mental error as an actual error?

Last night during the Indians game, Orioles 2nd baseman Hanser Alberto had a mental lapse that allowed the Indians to score a run instead of getting an inning ending double play.  It was scored as a fielders choice instead of an error and Anthony took an exception to that...Daryl disagreed and a fun segment ensued.
00:16:00